This is partially me getting stuff off my chest. This post isn’t a response to, but was partially inspired by a dumpster fire of a thread from a couple days ago that appears to be deleted now.
I was lucky enough to be raised going to a Lutheran church that was “one of the good ones.” Going through confirmation was my first formalized exposure to thinking philosophically in a way public schools don’t teach. It was through the lens of the Bible, but the discussions we had were on finding our own interpretations and meanings on what’s right. It’s where I learned the phrase “sin boldly,” something I’ve internalized to this day as accepting that I can’t be perfect but to keep moving forward. At the end I had to give a faith statement and told my pastor to his face that I wasn’t certain I believed in this God guy but I liked a lot of the lessons, and he was fine with that.
I’m pretty agnostic at this point, though I wouldn’t call myself atheist, but my religious experience has pretty much always been a good one. The last time I went to church a few years ago they outright welcomed gay, trans, and other oppressed people and offered opportunities to do good in the community.
Whenever I see online atheists hating on religion, my instinct is to get defensive because my experience with it has been good. But since I became an adult it’s also become clear to me that a lot of religious people suck and use their religion as a shield and a cudgel to act hatefully. Piping up and saying “not all religious people” rings about the same as saying “not all men” though, so I usually just don’t say anything, especially in explicitly atheist spaces. But I felt a need to express my feelings, and this seemed an appropriate way to do so.
There’s a different comm called “justpost”. Just bringing that up since this was deleted before. Anyway…
“I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.” ~ Ghandi (allegedly, though snopes says it’s unknown).
Not everything religions teach is all bad. Not every religious group is all bad. All of the important teachings and community can be had without religion, though, and that would outweigh the bad that comes with the religious groups/teachings.
The church I attended most probably did harm in my life than good. I’ve said online before that I would have easily fallen into the far-right christian-nationalist facist fuckhead pipeline had social media been a thing; I was partyway their anyway until my probably my mid-20s. I was a good christian for the most part, but not a good person.
I’m also now an atheist. I’m glad that you found a group that helped, but how have they been to all the other people in their communities and the world? I tend to think organized religion definitely and even supernatural thinking generally do far more harm in the world than good.
That’s great. And as soon as other people stop using it to oppress people for no good reason, I’ll stop hating all religions.
This is like saying you made lifelong friends in the KKK. Even if you all ended up getting out and getting better, it’s still weird to say the KKK had a positive impact on your life.
“Good Christians” in particular should be either much more vocal about rejecting their fascist counterparts, or just call themselves something else entirely. Preferably both.
Being a part of a community has positive effects. The religion is incidental.
I just want to say (a)gnostic is a different thing than (a)theist. Gnosticism is knowing —or rather the belief that you know. Theism is if there is a god. You can be both an gnostic or agnostic theist or atheist. If you don’t know that there isn’t a god, and don’t believe in one, then you’re an agnostic atheist. Atheism itself isn’t the belief that there isn’t a god. That’s a gnostic atheist.
By the way: Standing up for minorities and disadvantaged people also happens to be what Jesus taught.
I know there’s lots of people who call themselves Christians, who hate on homosexuals, women, trans folks etc. But the unfortunate reality is: They just got everything wrong. They believe pretty much in the polar opposite of what’s right according to their own literature.
Edit: And your link doesn’t work, it errors out, dunno if it got deleted.
If you try to be good while living in accordance to antic texts, you have to interpret and adapt those texts to your context.
Same if you are a cunt using those texts as an excuse.
Both are about interpretation just the same.
It’s hard, if not impossible, to write truly universal stories or rules.
The new testament isn’t exactly tolerant about everything.
Well… That’s kind of open to debate, isn’t it? Some people like to pick paragraphs which align with what they want to do and then assert this has to be followed literally. Some people say we need to interpret the stories.
I mean I know the earth isn’t 6000 years old, the universe wasn’t created by God in 6 days etc… We developed science since then and that gives us a fairly good answer to some of the big questions. But I have a hunch a lot of people read the Bible because they think there’s some “truth” embedded in there. Or some morals to follow.
When in reality, of course you shouldn’t follow any of the morals of the Bible. Because it’s filled with old stories which normalise selling your daughters and other heinous things. Or the sexist teachings of Paul in the newer parts. And of course lots of ommissions because the prophets of back then weren’t aware of how I live here in the modern city with all that technology, a fridge etc. So I can eat all the pork and shrimp I like and don’t have to follow the old rules.
But I think there’s some limitations. I mean once a text means anything and its opposite, it’s kinda worthless. And there isn’t much to interpret anymore.
But why shouldn’t there be truly universal stories or rules? I mean our origin story according to science is pretty much universal? That’s the point of science, to find objective answers. And I think we also have universal rules. For example the Golden Rule is a nice one to live by. It certainly is subject to nuance and doesn’t solve any situation… But it’s fairly good, a 5 yo can understand it and it’s difficult to abuse. And once I look at political/society stuff like the Human Rights declaration, which has almost universally been signed by all the sane representatives of societies… That’s also a fairly absolute guideline about what we should strive for.
“Not tolerant”!?!?! Religions use their bullshit texts to justify hate, murder, and genocide. Can you think of any genocides that are solely caused by religion? Right now. Anywhere in the world? Maybe the Middle-East?! Hmm?
The bible is a hate book. It spreads hate and division.
“But I don’t read that part!” Doesn’t matter, others do.
I would argue it’s a book used by hateful people to project themselves on to.
As the previous poster said, it’s left purposefully vague. A good lyric from an ACDC song was that religion is the blanket we throw over the mystery to give it shape.
And in that same way, we reflect ourselves back in it.
I think it did get deleted, I updated the post. Thanks for pointing that out.
What did telling you about an unprovable judgemental god add to your education?
If you had received a similar education but without the concept of “sin” or damnation, would that education have been inferior?
I, too, was raised in religion but I cannot know how my life would be if I hadn’t been indoctrinated to think less of myself (sinful) and humanity (in need of salvation) in general, I doubt you can know, either.
“What did telling you about an unprovable judgemental god add to your education?“
It predisposed me to thinking deeply about the world that I would later flesh out studying philosophy in college. Asking “are the words in the Bible the literal words of God or inspired by them” planted a seed for epistemology and where knowledge comes from. Considering morals in biblical stories is just ethics. At an age when school mostly meant learning facts how to do specific things (which are good things to teach) in confirmation we were asked questions with less clear answers. We were told what our church proposed but were then immediately given the space to question that and come to our own conclusions. English class is the closest to that, but then the focus is also split on analyzing characters and writing well.
“If you had received a similar education but without the concept of “sin” or damnation, would that education have been inferior?”
I was raised in a church that taught damnation hasn’t really been a thing for a couple millennia so it’s not too relevant for my experience. If you take sin to mean “doing something bad” then I think any education that discusses ethics, the thinking of right and wrong, would be inferior without the concept of wrong.
It’s true that I can’t know how things would be different if I wasn’t raised religious, but so many things (like my parents’ own upbringing) would have to change for that different possibility that I just don’t think it’s worth thinking about very much. Like I said in my original post thinking on that Martin Luther quote “sin boldly” taught me to embrace my own shortcomings rather than beat myself up for them. I don’t think religion should make someone feel lesser, and I’m sorry that was your experience.
It’s community that had a positive influence on you, not the woowoo magic daddy worship. I’m glad for you that you found a place with more of the former than the latter.
I grew up as a fundamentalist Southern Baptist. I got better.
My dad has been Christian all his life, still is. But he generally keeps it to himself unless asked. And while it took him extra long to really accept LGBTQ+ and the like, he pretty much has. He pretty much believes that everyone has to decide for themselves.
If I had grown up as that type of Christian, I might still be.
But because I didn’t, and because Christian Nationalists are one of several major forces bringing fascism to my country, it’s not just Christianity that can fuck off as far as I’m concerned, but pretty much most religions. I have a soft spot in my heart for pagans as I was one for a little bit, and the ones I knew were all pretty much laid back delightful folks. And I tend to give Sikhs some respect because as far as I can tell, they largely are doing what they say they believe, and humbly taking care of their fellow human beings.
I’m not totally against religion, but if the subject comes up without any further context, most of my experiences have been rather more negative than positive.
So far as I’m concerned - enjoy your religion. Do what you can to live up to it. I hope you choose the right ethical and moral choices. But even if you don’t, long as you keep the fuck out of legislating my life, more power to ya. And if you DO believe in keeping it out of our laws, then I firmly support your religious choices. Even if I bitch about the others who are not like that, because that’s what I hate - the ones trying to control my life, others’ lives, taking away human rights.
So as an atheist, I’ll say: Not all religions, or at least not all religious? Gladly give you that.
And if there’s an atheist who says “make it illegal to be Christian”, well, I don’t support that. But I sure also haven’t heard anyone saying that. heh
If you’re willing to accept obvious lies as reality, you’ve already lost the game. Nothing that you say can be trusted. Your reality has been warped beyond the ability to recognize reality from complete fiction. Right now, you choosing to believe in fiction is permanently harming your brain’s ability to reason.
Anyone taking you at your word, or your advice is just as stupid and reckless as you are.
Yet another religious idiot saying “NO, I am the only real christian/muslim/hindu/etc!!! Everyone else is wrong, and I’m willing to fight and die over it.”
All christians say that. Every fucking single one. You’re not special, you’re a cultist now.
So it’s obvious you didn’t read the post at all.
Bravo, that is unpopular on lemmy.
Not exactly an opinion though, more a statement about an aspect of their life.
Yeah, this is a data point (an outlier for that matter), not an opinion.
It could be formulated as an opinion: “not every religious experience is terrible”. It would be a very weak opinion, because almost everything has outliers. I know for a fact that there are positive reports by Jews who were interned during WW2.
I’m so happy for you!!! It does indeed sound like a positive impact for you. Understanding how religion has been used against minorities is important, but it also doesn’t preclude faith, community and learning healthy philosophy.
I was one of the top comments in that other thread explaining why so many atheist criticize the religious so it feels appropriate to respond here as well. Ultimately my religious childhood was fraught with judgment shame, guilt but the one thing I did enjoy was Sunday school being the only place morality was discussed. I clashed with those teachers often for their narrow views on right and wrong, but looking back in still thankful for the discussions. It got me reading philosophy outside the church. In a way those talks led me to my own current atheistic not-religion-but-sorta-takes-the-slot-of-religion, veganism. The ethical framework I use to determine right and wrong.
Church also unintentionally taught me not to push those beliefs on others. I put great effort into biting my tongue when animal exploitation is brought up around family. I’ll never be the activist on the street because I abhor the pastors on the street.
I’m glad you can recognize the limitations of religion, why still finding the positives. The original poster from the other day seemed to stop thinking at “y r atheists so mean 2 me?!?” without understanding the greater context. You embraced the nuance.
Good post.
Sure. I’ve known people who enjoyed their religious upbringing. More if you count the Unitarians.
Many people have suffered because of people using religion, so it’s not surprising people have a negative opinion. Christianity has a lot of stuff in it like “love your neighbor”, “you will be judged by how you treat the least among you”, and “give your wealth to the poor”, but people manage to use it to be assholes.
It sounds like you may have attended an evangelical (ironic, I know) Lutheran church. A pity the Missouri Synod is the polar opposite.
I’ve had good and bad experiences in churches.
I looked it up and you’re right! It is an evangelical Lutheran church. I count myself lucky for a lot of the experiences I was born into, sorry it sounds like your experience differed in such a negative way.
I’ve attended both Lutheran churches, tht’s how I guessed! I’ve made peace with my faith, which is eclectic, I guess. But being reared Christian is a default reference for me. But I had to go back to Judaism, kabbalah, and the Ethiopian Bible to get a richer, fuller understanding. That’s what brought me back to my faith.
People don’t admit it, but religion evolved with us to suit the needs of the flock. Going to it for help is a reasonable thing to do, and they don’t even really test or judge you so long as you maintain performances these days. Each religion has it’s black spots, but it’s largely composed of people trying to do good things for themselves and others. Surrounding yourself with those kinds of people is bound to get you something.
it’s largely composed of people trying to do good things for themselves and others
I don’t think this is necessarily the case. Charity is part of many religions. But that’s also frequently not what the majority of groups do. It is motivating people to do things. But that can be very well be some holy crusades with killing people, cutting down on freedom and abusing women like the religious leaders for example in Afghanistan do. Or a simple cash grab plus power over people like the Evangelicals in America do.
All I know is, there’s stuff done in the name of religion. And good things as well! Which is indeed a good thing. But I think it’s really a mixed bag in the grand scale. Even more so historically.
If you accept it’s not perfect, like any organization, and sometimes it hurts people outside the group it’s not so different than a lot of groups we form as humans. My thesis is it’s just team sports. You’re focusing on the thing as a whole as well. At an individual level, most people would benefit from some sort of religion if they could stomach it. Religion didn’t evolve to commune with gods, it evolved to keep people coming to church and maintain the flock. It’s a very specific form of exchange that goes beyond stuff and things. It’s also democratic, so when men of the church decide to oppress or the pope declares a crusade - usually means the wrong person got in the driver seat. People react to this and we’re still here to talk down to it today. It’s actually all just a part of the whole process.
How is that democratic or good, though? The popes are just a long list of people having blood on their hands. Including to this day causing unnecessary harm and death on a whole continent. There’s cover-up operations for the crimes their priests commit. To the highest ranks. And nobody in the catholic church likes any of that. The evangelical megachurch leaders are universally selfish egomaniacs who spread hate and fly private jets. And in countries with sharia law they’re just all the same group of people and try to make women suffer as much as they can do.
And as far as I know there isn’t much people were able to do?! You’d just get killed. Or expelled from the group in more moderate societies/religions. It’s not like people haven’t tried… But religious leadership tends to be fairly powerful and brutal. And not open to hear suggestions.
You’re very fortunate if you happen to be part of the one or two denominations who elect their priests / leadership. But that’s not what the vast majority of people gets to experience.
(My sports group is democratic, though. We’ll meet up once a year and write down what to do. And every three years or so, we elect a new leader and they have to implement that. And we don’t have any blood on our hands. Worst thing was some broken glasses.)
I didn’t say it was good. It’s a horrific part of our behavior, but it seems it’s the best we could manage at the time. I think you’re taking this a little personally or just being a little obtuse. I’m comparing religion to aircraft or cars, or some kind of machine. The person operating it can use it to evil ends, and even modify the machine to increase the throughput. However these are more notable exceptions than rules. If you accept that religion might make armies invade and kill, then you must also accept it the other way around. Really you should just see it for the construction it is. People make religion and follow it because they want to, because it benefits them, because it gives them a place in the universe that most atheists have to spend time working out on their own. It’s a choice. Most religions are no more dangerous than government, because they’re essentially the same thing working in different niches. When the crusades happened or pastors raped kids, people just stood by and let it happen? No, they get ousted or outed eventually. It’s nothing to do specifically with any power system that wouldn’t also be applicable to any other power system. Politicians and Priests hurt people with their power, it’s not the power, it’s them. Writing off the whole thing is just millennial feel good cope crap and I won’t have it. I go to church picnics because good people gather there, it’s not any more complicated than that.
No system of power lasts forever. Somebody is going to find the bones buried in the backyard someday. Better just to not put them there in the first place. Accept any flower you grow might die someday, or someone may burry a body back there anyway, but don’t hold back from doing anything out of the fear it might not be perfect.
Yeah, sorry I didn’t want come off as obtuse. Guess it’s more being annoyed.
I mean I grew up catholic. And there’s quite some things I’m not okay with concerning the catholic church. Things many people don’t like. For example their stance towards women, people who aren’t heterosexual. People who they employ and who happen to get divorced, their stance towards contraceptives… All of that isn’t just part of history, but severe issues as of today.
And we’ve been trying to talk to the church for like 50 years now?! And they never listen. And it got considerably worse for the church. The last decades people realized there’s nothing in it for them. So they voted with their feet and left. And now the church struggles with income and all kinds of things, has to close churches and in a few years they’re probably going to go extinct…
But does that make them reconsider or repent or modernize? Of course not!
That’s kind of the main thing. And all the misconduct comes on top. But what am I supposed to do with that? I mean I’d applaud them and maybe resume contributing if they for example offered places for young people to do projects in the afternoon. But they’re also(!) closing those because they’re not interested in investing in young people unless it’s the altar servers. (Or profitable daycares.) They also don’t really contribute a lot to my own life…
So what’s left for me except feeling disillusioned?
(I’ve also talked a bit to people from the other big Christian denomination here. And it’s a similar story with them. They’re more modern than we are, but there’s also a lot of systemic issues, they also have their followers dwindle and I just don’t see a lot of stuff on the positive side with them, either.)








