(I get the feeling weāre close to this bubbleās end.)
Anyways, welcome to the Stubsack, your first port of call for learning fresh Awful youāll near-instantly regret.
Any awful.systems sub may be subsneered in this subthread, techtakes or no.
If your sneer seems higher quality than you thought, feel free to cutānāpaste it into its own post ā thereās no quota for posting and the bar really isnāt that high.
The post Xitter web has spawned soo many āesotericā right wing freaks, but thereās no appropriate sneer-space for them. Iām talking redscare-ish, reality challenged āculture criticsā who write about everything but understand nothing. Iām talking about reply-guys who make the same 6 tweets about the same 3 subjects. Theyāre inescapable at this point, yet I donāt see them mocked (as much as they should be)
Like, there was one dude a while back who insisted that women couldnāt be surgeons because they didnāt believe in the moon or in stars? I think each and every one of these guys is uniquely fucked up and if I canāt escape them, I would love to sneer at them.
(Credit and/or blame to David Gerard for starting this.)
āI like the idea of trying to integrate AI components into guitars, where you can prompt a guitar to sound a certain way. Iād like to explore that.ā
Matt Bellamy, frontman of band Muse
I see that my unawareness of a certain aspect of pop culture has spared me from disappointment yet again.
not muse pls
unfortunately he is a fair bit of a twat. I was also disappointed when I learned about it a few years ago
why canāt Rats get laid, reason #12,906
Almost everybody attending a rationalist event is going to be some brand of cosmopolitan internationalist nerd, whether they accept it or not.
Words fail me. A few CFAR people had contacts in Czechia and Germany but most of these people canāt dare to explore exotic subcultures in their own city, and race pseudoscience is central to their culture.
I think thereās an inbuilt unexamined assumption that they are automatically part of a cosmopolitan elite, thanks to their paths through early life, and they are now transcending beyond that. Standing on the shoulders of David Brooks, perhaps
At best, I think ācosmopolitanā means āwants to stay at a Hilton on three continents, and gets off to Japanese and American porn.ā
Someone diagnosed the Post-Rationalists as bring resentful that their educations and class backgrounds did not bring them the wealth, power, and status they felt they deserved.
ā¦Standing on the shoulders of David Brooks, perhaps
Old: Taco Tuesday
Bold: Savage Saturday
One comment at the moment:
Or maybe theyāre just racists, and trying to impress a woman is a convenient excuse?
With, shockingly, three out of three upvotes (but one agree balancing one disagree)
Rationalists blurt out racist stuff
P(rationalists are racist) ~ epsilon and since P(say racists things) * P(I observe rationalists say racist things) is very high we must still deeper.
P(say racist) = P(are racist) * P(other reasons) ergo P(other reasons) must be very high. So they must be impressing women.
I have pretended to do science. Please clap.
Possibly the modal jarring experience is that theyāre talking alone with a nice man who seems pretty normal (if a little awkward), and that guy will just inject a conspicuously racist comment into their conversation. Not like a casual comment that seems unfortunate in context, or an edgy comment in a discussion that was already dancing around race, but something completely out of the blue.
How could such epistemically healthy individuals possibly be racists, literally unthinkable.
I know what actual chuds are like. That being the case, when I see this behavior from rationalists firsthand (again, usually in front of a woman), it often strikes me as bizarre and performative.
Then a few paragraphs later he starts delineating the types of racism he finds acceptable:
people making these comments are usually not āactuallyā racist. Almost everybody attending a rationalist event is going to be some brand of cosmopolitan internationalist nerd, whether they accept it or not. And if theyāre not, theyāre still not going to be racist in the way that a guy from San Antonio whose relatives used the N word at the dinner table is racist. Their āracismā was internalized as a result of a passive and NPC-like relationship with social media, and is fundamentally uninteresting to outside observers.
Basically if you were being racist (charismatically) I donāt think OP would have a problem.
Went for āclassyā racism but got classist instead
š¶ Canāt shake the Devilās hand and say youāre only kidding š¶
Completely forgot about the interactive AI model forecast graph from Kokotajlo and friends
Nothingās changed aside from a small disclaimer linking to their most recent blog post (discussed here)
Only thing noteworthy is that Kokotajloās model has an AI Coder that ācan fully automate an AGI projectās coding work, replacing the projectās entire software engineering staffā, so get ready!
Peeked back at their blog to see if I could find anything about it. Text dump incoming:
The model with Danielās latest median parameters predicted that when an Automated Coder (AC) was developed, AI software R&D uplift would be ~2.7x and the pace of progress would be accelerated from the 2024.0-2025.5 level by ~1.25x.
So naively, if weāre at a 1.7x AI-attributed pace of progress multiplier, we might think that AC has been achieved (as of Model 4).
Based on the METR report and Anthropicās Fable 5.2 system card, it seems unlikely but not totally implausible.
In the Fable 5.2 system card: Anthropic says: āwe have been using Claude Mythos 5.2 extensively in our own day-to-day research and engineering during the pre-release period, and it does not seem close to being able to substitute for our Research Scientists and Research Engineers.ā This is the strongest evidence against AC already. On the other hand, METR surprisingly doesnāt rule out full AI R&D automation: āWe are uncertain, but think itās unlikely that [Claude Mythos 5.2] can fully automate the AI R&D process at Anthropic.ā Fable 5.2, based on its AECI, likely represents āModel 3,ā which is the second-most-capable internally deployed Anthropic model.
Idk man that seems like that pretty solidly means AC did not happen
Relevant interview quotes from the METR report include: Being āno longer bottlenecked on code,ā āSWE acceleration⦠is extremely substantial.ā āWhen people present experiments, they most often just point to an [agent scaffold] thread. Experimentation overhead is driven towards zero super fast.ā Thereās also the reportās assessments on automating researchers beyond coding:
āWe were told that R&D is accelerated primarily via AI assistance rather than fully autonomous contributions, but there are some signs that fully autonomous contributions will play a larger role soonā. āSimply put, Anthropic tries hard to substitute researchers out for models, but researchers are still required.ā Note that humans could still contribute some alongside an AC: the criterion is that only the AIs could do all the coding as well as only the humans.
ok and?? if only the AIs could do the work then they wouldnāt be having trouble substituting out researchers for AI.
In the reportās chart showing āModel 4 achieves >50% on all of its benchmarksā, there is a software engineering benchmark on which Model 4 gets ~52%, and another around ~75%. Surprisingly, on the 52% one, scores have been getting worse since Mythos 5. This makes me discount it substantially, but still itās informative that Anthropic chose to include it in the AECI. The progression for the 75% one looks more reasonable; Eli thinks these benchmarks provide weak evidence against AC. (Not strong evidence, because humans might also score well under 100%.)
My take is that if there was an AI model that could automate all the coding on Anthropicās AI projects, it would be absolutely plastered all over the news. Especially with their IPO looking shakier and shakier by the day. Plus if theyāre apparently trying to replace researchers but canāt thatās a pretty strong indicator that AC isnāt here
I am sick and tired of all this benchmark business. It really feels like people staring at tea leaves and bird patterns and sheep guts to see if they line up with the prophecy written in the book some random shady oracle sold them 200 years ago. If they wanted a clear picture, why donāt they just ask a practitioner in the field? Ask a programmer if software has become very reliable and user-friendly, and if codebases are well-structured and easy to maintain and not spaghetti nightmares. Or they could just open their eyes and see Microsoft and the FAA shitting their pants on two consecutive days. But I guess itās not Rational if it doesnāt let them make up 37 numbers.
Itās like theyāre auditioning for chief jargon guy āIf only we could modulate the tachyon flux by disharging the deflector dish, we could form a rudimentary turboencabulator. We benchmarked the dilithium crystal matrix, which bottlenecked our capacity to inhibit exponential takeoff, but indicators are negative.ā
if we word salad hard enough weāll manifest the Robot God
Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular financing deals, report claims
pretty sure we all knew this one, but what the hell more evidence doesnt hurt
My face when reading awful this week (positive):

The funniest part of Jensengate is seeing all the techbros being really sad and petitioning to restore Jensen to his rightful position, thinking that there is some analogy to Sam Altman. They seem to not realize that the reason Saltman was fired was because the board didnāt like his stupid face. Meanwhile, Jensen has committed three affairs, two with employees, and somehow that is the less important thing, considering he smuggled tens of billions of dollars of chips illegally into China. I wouldnāt be surprised if he ends up in jail. If Jensen thought he had a reasonable chance of surviving, why would he resign and start whining like a teenager?
They even built a vibe coded petition website with zero user validation whatsoever:

I think the board drama at OpenAI was the EA cultists (led by Ilya Sutskever) realising that Sama wasnāt a true believer but a cynical capitalist - the real life embodiment of the Simpsons monorail salesman. They realised he wasnāt going to take their fairytale about an omnipotent digital sneky seriously and tried to fire him. He was able to get back in due to support from his tech industry allies who are also uber capitalists (like Nadella)
the reason Saltman was fired was because the board didnāt like his stupid face.
He did lie to them and tell different people different stories to try to manipulate them. But you are right among the things he lied about was AI āsafetyā related stuff, and (as samvines describes) he lied because he wasnāt a true believer like they were. (And thus tried to bypass their oversight in releasing ChatGPT.)
Lukewarm take, considering that LLM models could use a lot more thought and care in their development and release (although obviously not for the reasons the doomers want), the EA cultists were actually the (relatively) good guys in that whole saga of Sam Altmanās firing and rehiring.
under no circumstances you āgotta hand it to themā
I donāt know, Iām not gonna root for an arsonist on the Hindenburg even if it is full of Nazis.
And also finally the circular financing stuff is making headlines, probably because they think they can pin it all on the one guy. Even the executive CEO is explicitly described as someone who was apprehensive with the whole propping up startups long enough for them to order a gazillion GPUs thing.
full article about it here apparently over 6800 Nvidia employees have signed, but then again no user validation so we have no idea what the real number is
Jensen Huang discussing a comeback to Nvidia with his supporters
Mate, YOU RESIGNED. None of this āuhh actually I wanna go backā bullshit. Iām sure Nvidiaās board would love to take back the CEO whoās getting investigated for violating export controls
āDonāt quote corporate governance norms to MEN WITH GPUS!ā
Why not simply make Claude the ceo of Nvidia?
#chatCEO already!
A story of two halves
Yesterday

Today

Just remembered I had this piece of rationalist word salad saved for later

the context is that dude was arguing that anyone who understands the āpotential of the techā knows that it is an existential risk and that you only need a laymanās understanding to know that. (he specifically said that āa sufficiently intelligent five year oldā could figure it out) and when I argued against him this is what I got in reply
i donāt understand, are there trees or are there not? should we plant trees? is it futile? should we dig a ditch?
also am i a tree?
Quite clearly they have understood that planting trees (as in planting trees) is in direct opposition to the rolling boulder (as in slopbots). Therefore we should stop planting trees so that we may be more effectively crushed by the boulder (slopbot).
A Quality Shitpost⢠from fedi regarding recent events, courtesy of Jared White:

Alt-text, to maximise shitpost transmissibility
A screenshot of a Simpsons episode (donāt know which one), featuring Kwik-E-Mart owner and controversy magnet Apu (labelled āWeird Nerdsā) jumping in front of a would-be shooter (labelled āEthical Frameworkā) to save an employee (labelled āFreedom 0ā)
mutual aid but for your agents :^)
Proudhon would never
This is the exact opposite of mutual aid
Nvidia Employees Are Pushing for a Sam Altman 2.0
Before Nvidiaās board of directors announced Thursday morning that Huang would be stepping aside, to be replaced by longtime company CFO Colette Kress, a veteran engineer at Nvidia submitted an internal post urging the board to take employee sentiment into account before making a final decision, Wired reported Thursday evening. It has since turned into a kind of petition for the disgraced ex-CEOās return, garnering more than 1,600 comments, many of which are reportedly supportive of Huangās reinstatement as CEO.
Not at Sam Altman return levels of backlash yet
why donāt they make AI Jensen in the digital factory so itās like he never left and then they can kiss him each night and tuck him into bed.
Seriously, what the fuck is melting peopleās brains out there. Is everybody in the bay area poisoned by ergot?
the commerce secretary is also testifying about Nvidiaās chip exports before the banking committee
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has agreed to testify before the Senate banking committee on December 10 over questions involving Nvidiaās chip exports to China.
Wonātcha look at that. Now that MAGA isnāt hot shit anymore, Alex Karp goes full āHow do you do, fellow Democratsā and says Palantir has basically always been a progressive company.
https://www.businessinsider.com/alex-karp-palantir-democrat-progressive-midterms-2026-11

Alex Karp will say anything that will let him take coke and murder people.
In the style of āclaims to be pro-life, dies anywayā: claims to be a Democrat, dismantles democracy anyway
Outlook was down for an entire day yesterday, which affected me since my school email uses it. I donāt remember any Outlook outage this bad before, and from what Iāve heard, Microsoft was cosplaying as a headless chicken in their attempts to fix it. Maybe getting rid of 60,000 employees to embrace the magic of AI isnāt working out so well.
Meanwhile I saw this AI panic post on Linkedin (warning: psychic damage). Apparently all the doomers are vindicated and all the critics are completely discredited because of ⦠you guessed it, math problems! You see, one mathematician was very sad in an interview! (Letās also ignore the many nuanced statements like this that mathematicians have made about their own field.)
But somehow he hasnāt noticed AI affecting anything he actually understands. Well, you see, thatās because in the real world, the magic of AI does need to wait a few years before the puny humans understand how to wield its power (but of course the doomsday is coming on schedule in a few years). The argument sounds nice until you look at of software, where there should be no physical obstacles for adopting AI. Now, coding has been solved by AI on the planet of Earth Prime where he lives, where OpenAI and Anthropic have long monopolized every software market with products of much higher quality and reliability than what came before. Unfortunately, I live on Earth, where I have seen two major vibe-coding failures in the last two days (the Outlook outage and the Humble Store rewrite).
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7xJeaAKTKxbHL6F9a/a-new-kind-of-prediction-market-for-science
Got a problem of randos shitting AI-generated ARXIV preprints into existence faster than the scientific community can deal with it? SHOEHORN IN PREDICTION MARKETS!
(Incidentally, my boss has been complaining about the onslaught of low quality preprints that are shat out with the usual low-quality signifiers that let you filter things being harder to immediately see, and his conclusion is that he is sad to say science is going back towards and has to go back towards systems of reputation and patronage where you have to look at who lent their reputation to a work and who newcomers are being vouched for by to determine if it is worth looking at it at all.)
(And I am again reminded of our electronic information sphere becoming like the Earthās genetic information sphere in that it is full of selfish parasites looking to hijack you to use their nonproductive information, with productive cellular life jealously guarding its genomic nucleic acids and not letting it interact with the froth of selfish viral and mobile elements bouncing off it at all times.)
Math 3.0: exploiting Lean bugs to scam bettors on Kalshi












