DS9: It’s real!
TNG: What is reality?
TOS: Kirk beating up a philosopher probably
Aight. Hot take incoming
So, back when I was a kid, the late seventies and early eighties in specific, every boy I knew watched wrestling. Plenty of girls too.
Even back then, the kayfabe was part of the fun, even back as far as kindergarten. Most of us knew that who won matches was predetermined. We knew damn good and well not to do the crazy shit the wrestlers did because no way was it safe.
And, later on, we knew damn good and well that hulk Hogan wasn’t getting stronger and recovering when he got hit.
But it was fun. It was part soap opera, part cartoon, part action movie fight scene. Again, the kayfabe was part of the fun. You knew it wasn’t people fighting, it was a demo, an example of what could be done by the human body, not grown ass men trying to hurt each other. Oh, nobody would have said it that way, and there were people that swallowed the kayfabe all the way, but you’d have two guys cutting promos, talking about how bad they were going to fuck each other up for weeks, and then wait until summer slam or whatever to do it. It wasn’t real life, and even the little kids got that.
But go back a generation or two, and wresting was different. You had more actual wrestling in it as opposed to stunt work. The kayfabe was easier to swallow, and more people did. My own grandmother would say that rasslin weren’t real like it used to be. And, being real, you can watch old matches and tell damn good and well that even the best chain wrestlers weren’t wrestling the way you’d do on a mat in school or collegiate wrestling.
Fast forward to the nineties, you get more stunts, less rasslin. Fast forward again, and you’ve got the tightly choreographed dances of today. The real difference over time is the expectations of the audience. You want viewers to be wowed, you have to keep upping the show. Inevitably, you reach a point of absurdity. Whether that’s been reached or not is a matter of some debate
But what has remained real is that it’s a very physically demanding activity even just to practice. It’s athletic as hell. It’s dangerous as hell, even without the kind of shit that happened to Owen Hart.
And there is, even now where they pump instructions into the ears of the wrestlers directly, some degree of improvisation that takes an underlying grasp of what fighting is. It won’t be the same as a real fight, but the best way to keep safe with what they do is the same basic set of skills you learn in martial arts to keep from being injured while practicing. It’s about body mechanics, building muscle memory so you can respond on the fly, developing your mind-body connection and proprioception.
So it is a sport, if no more so than rhythmic gymnastics. But instead of being judged by a panel, you’re judged by the audience and the company bigshots making the calls. It’s still competitive, if not purely based on objective criteria. So, it a absolutely is real. And it is a sport. It is also scripted.
It’s real athleticism; it’s fake fighting.
We’re watching stunts, and its great
Pro wrestling once had the perfect tagline: “It’s not fake, it’s unreal!” 🤣
It’s basically low brow Cirque du Soleil or Peking Opera.
It’s real in the sense they are doing hard and dangerous acrobatics, it’s fake in the sense they aren’t actually fighting and are playing a badly scripted role.
The bad scripting is the best part
The real housewives of the wrestling arena.
star trek loving pro wrestling fan here, in regards to both:
“IT’S REAL TO ME DAMMIT”
Professional wrestling is a type of soap opera whose target audience is boys.
Soap opera shōnen
A soap opera with spandex and steroids.
“Soap Opera”

WWE is pro wrestling Pro wrestling isn’t WWE
Ain’t no wrestling going on in that. That’s just synchronized bleeding.
So tell me Andre, is what you do even real?

Apparently there’s a story of him and Arnold Schwarzenegger fighting over who pays for booze one night, and Andre lifted Arnold up onto the high window sill of a building and walked off to pay.
I hear he was a really good guy.
It’s really fake.

It’s both.
Exactly.
I personally find pro wrestling pointless, when there are so many human competitions that don’t have their results 99.99% scripted, and are thus far more interesting to me.
But I do recognize that they bang themselves up a lot to perform their fake fights, and their commitment and work ethic is very real, even if their “sport” isn’t.
If wrestling is fake explain how the pants kicked out at two?
Is that Jumbo Joe Thornton?
Sisko seems like the kind of guy who would be in to real wrestling, to be honest.
What it is, is scripted. Look at any analysis of the Mankind/Undertaker Hell in a Cell cage match. Taker was always gonna throw Foley off the cage onto the announcer table. The table was sorted to prepare for it. The fall hurt Foley more than expected, so the “medics” took their time wheeling him up the ramp. He was always gonna get back up. He wasn’t supposed to fall through the roof of the cageto. The chair wasn’t supposed to fall after himto, hit him in the mouth, and knock out his teeth. They improvised back to script after that. The fall, the chair, Taker on top of the cage looking dumbfounded while it raised so the real medics could check on him — all real. They played it off well though. Both of them absolutely the best at what they did.
The table was sorted to prepare for it.
It was the Spanish announcer table. Actually fully assembling one has never been accomplished.
That was an amazing match.
Wrestling is both real and fake in the same way ballet is both real and fake — the story is scripted, but you still have to do the feats of athleticism.
I know plenty of people who watch, none of whom seem to think it’s anything other than entertainment scripted like reality TV.
Even if they don’t know the specifics of how a match will go, they all have a part to play and an outline at the very least.
The difference is that people don’t call ballet dancers athletes and describe it as a sport. It’s rightly recognised for the extremely intense art form that it is.
I just love the phrase “scripted reality TV”. Haha, well said
Buncha smarks in this thread 😉
Wrong argument entirely:
The outcomes and storylines may be scripted, but that doesn’t make it fake: they do some pretty damn impressive stunts that can seriously hurt or even kill them if not done right by ALL involved.















