Is Everyone Conscious in the Same Way? | Simon Roper - eviltoast
  • bunchberry@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    4 months ago

    Bruh. We literally don’t even know what consciousness is.

    You are starting from the premise that there is this thing out there called “consciousness” that needs some sort of unique “explanation.” You have to justify that premise. I do agree there is difficulty in figuring out the precise algorithms and physical mechanics that the brain uses to learn so efficiently, but somehow I don’t think this is what you mean by that.

    We don’t know how anesthesia works either, so he looked into that and the best he got was it interrupts a quantom wave collapse in our brains

    There is no such thing as “wave function collapse.” The state vector is just a list of probability amplitudes and you reduce those list of probability amplitudes to a definite outcome because you observed what that outcome is. If I flip a coin and it has a 50% chance of being heads and a 50% chance of being tails, and it lands on tails, I reduce the probability distribution to 100% probability for tails. There is no “collapse” going on here. Objectifying the state vector is a popular trend when talking about quantum mechanics but has never made any sense at all.

    So maybe Roger Penrose just wasted his retirement on this passion project?

    Depends on whether or not he is enjoying himself. If he’s having fun, then it isn’t a waste.