The phrase is about what people should do, not what they actually do. You shouldn’t judge a book by its cover. However, you’re doing a bad job if you assume everyone actually will look past the cover. The cover doesn’t make a book good or bad, so you shouldn’t use it to form your opinion. However, it’s the only thing many people will see, so it better be good if you want them to buy/read it.
Truly unrelated, but: the song “The Look of Love” by ABC contained the line “if you judge a book by its cover, then you judge the look by the lover”. This always annoyed the shit out of me. Logically, it should have been “then you judge the lover by the look”, but of course that wouldn’t rhyme.
If the cover is AI generated I reckon you should judge the book by it’s cover.

Ironically, German boys of that era grew up on a steady diet of Westerns. In fact German pilots from both world wars referred to Allied fighter planes as “Indianer” or “Indian”.
Robert E. Howard created Conan the Barbarian back in the 1930s. The stories were sporadically reprinted for decades, but the character remained a minor figure, far behind the Lensmen or The Shadow.
All that changed when this cover came along…

100% on the mark with your observation, thank you. I will risk throwing in some explanatory prose to go with your point, because I don’t believe it’s obvious enough for all (though I do feel it is self-evidentiary, if one looks close enough)
If I stray from your point, please, do not hesitate to correct me:
A great cover won’t hide a poor book from the audience realizing it for long, but a poor cover will hide a great book from its audience for eternity.
There seems to be a belief in general culture that the adage ‘Don’t judge a book by its cover’ originates as a reader-borne observation, when in reality, it’s a writing floor copium entreaty to the literary gods as whispered by authors without a giant publishing house full of artists to help and a lack of artistic skill themselves.
I felt physical discomfort reading this. Well done.
I frequently judge books by their cover, especially sapphic books.
If the cover of your book looks like the literary equivalent of a Hallmark movie, I’m going to assume it’s of the same genre and caliber.
I understand there are budgetary constraints, but I would so much prefer a more boring cover to that slop.
The purpose of a book cover is so you will judge the book.
What do y’all think of the cover of my book?

And don’t read or buy that one; it’s garbage of no value. Read this free one instead (I changed my name when I became a woman and then again when I became a cyborg):
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KXt0EuhD4U5Pa2Jl050lscOfZi_UxOKQWz4oVewYUH0/edit?usp=drivesdk

The timing is too funny
I’ve found some of my favorite authors by browsing a bookstore and picking up books that looked aesthetically appealing to me.
Anyone else hate when hardcovers have literally nothing under the dust cover
I saw a book whose cover said it was quote-authored-unquote by James Patterson and Mr Beast. Pretty sure the cover told me everything I needed to know, including that neither James Patterson nor Mr Beast wrote a single word of it.
“Book”.
Well, I’m sure the people who did the typesetting, printing, binding, etc did a fine job, almost as good of a job as the people who will be inevitably shredding, pulping and recycling them into something more useful like the cardboard hats they have at hospitals to be sick into.
Ha ha, sometimes I love reading replies in my profile and not having any idea what comments I made to precipitate them. This one was solidly in that category.
Am I suppose to just read every book despite a bad cover? There’s a lot of good information on there, and far too many books to read.
I think the essential part is not judging without knowing what’s inside. Judge all you want, if you know the book is trash or great or anything in between. But if you didn’t read the book just hold your tongue. There really is no necessity to formulate any opinion then.
And am I supposed to read a bad book just because the cover was good?
Am I supposed to read a book just because it has a cover?
Yes, read all books
Am I supposed to read just because I know how to read?
I feel we’re just a few iterations away from “have you ever had a dream” meme but with “have you ever read a book”
Instead of going by the cover wait until two people from different social circles who don’t know each other independently recommend the same book to you. Then even if it isn’t “good” it’s probably something you would like.
And no one ever reads a book again while trying to follow this advice.
Also, consider old books.
Sensibilities changed, and the printing press gave acceleration to the practice unto absurdity compared to what came before as now the “cover” of a book is expected to be literally a different art form altogether.
But there was a before where it applied too. Gilding and illuminating for example.
A country Lord would still have preferred purchasing a copy of the same Psalm book from the monastery that does the fancy binding over the same book as bound in rabbit leather for the country priest.
I live by the mantra
“Never judge a book by it’s cover, always judge a wine by it’s label”
Curious to hear your sommelier opinion on this one then:
Warning: minor nudity and violence

I kinda liked the one with the bicycle






