@Dolores - eviltoast

Dolores [love/loves]

amerikkka 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥 ✋ 秦始皇

  • 10 Posts
  • 129 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 9th, 2022

help-circle

  • i think you’re imprinting much more of the present on the past than identifying antecedents that lead to the present.

    many, many, many, governments and people have evoked symbolism and rhetoric from rome and other ‘classical’ canons. but we don’t have to be credulous about those premises. in Roman and early medieval times, many chroniclers fabricated stories that x group of people were descended from a character in the Trojan War, or a tribe of israel from the first testament. we do not take these seriously, though some people surely earnestly subscribed to them.

    same goes for claiming to be heir to Rome’s Empire. its suitable for identifying an ambition, but unhelpful for analyzing whether a state developed from roman institutions or utilized roman political forms. eg: Holy Roman Empire–its in the name, yes. but absolutely no trace of roman political forms. romans did not have kings. Holy Roman Emperors could only rarely exercise authority over the bishops.

    another: USA, has a “senate” named like romans… but what is this house of representatives? who are the nobles? the fuck is a federalism? much todo was made of cloaking all these innovations in Aquilae and phrygian caps, but damn, even the Church Of Rome had almost no purchase in the US at founding

    tl;dr devil’s in the details, aesthetic refrains to romanism are not the same as concrete relationships to the roman past













  • you’re just asserting direct contradictions. UAF not destroyed—but they’re spent, more military–demilitarization. but i’m really not interested in the layers upon layers you need to understand Russia’s 20-year-plan that totally exists and guides every cautious or backward step the Russian army seems to make.

    if the Russians don’t want to destroy the UAF and continue the war in perpetuity, then the retreat at Adiivka (the event this comment thread is about) does not then herald a collapse of the Ukrainian position & the war will probably continue. which is what i was concluding, granted from different premises




  • the only way to demilitarize a state that is unwilling to do it is to destroy their army and their ability to fight

    all the more reason for Russia to move aggressively to envelop and destroy elements of the UAF like those ‘routing’ from these front line positions—if this is still too dangerous for Russia, the UAF must not be in that bad of a spot




  • no. greek people have existed, a greek state was a new creation specifically in the mould of 19th century european nationalism. the only thing they’d actually be guilty of on this chart is the internal genocide of minorities that is part-and-parcel to the national project.

    in any case there’s no political lineage and barely even a linguistic relationship from what i’m assuming your ancient events are, and the modern state. transcontinental african slave trade =/= someone being in a state of slavery on the african continent at any time in the past.

    sorry to be a pedant but the “slavery was in africa before” is a popular mystification from racists trying to equivocate the modern european crimes.