[CLOSED] a Beehaw survey on some policy and the site's vibes - eviltoast

good morning, Beehaw

this morning we have a survey for you, which will run for approximately three days. it contains three questions on site policy (plus an optional explanation field), and two questions about the site’s current vibe (plus another optional explanation field).

you can find the survey here.


some caveats to this survey

you likely have some priors for how this “should” work, and i would like you to leave those at the door. to be up front:

  • this is not a referendum—it is more like a Wikipedia vote if anything. we’re looking for a consensus or a synthesis of the community’s opinions with the practical limitations we’re working with, not a first-past-the-post winner.
  • this is not (currently) a democracy, and you should not expect public results from this. we talked this part over as an admin team and we don’t see much value in publicly releasing the results of a survey like this. if we do release the results publicly, we’ll be announcing that before it happens.
  • the same caveats just mentioned will apply to any surveys like this into the foreseeable future. i’m sure everyone understands that in online spaces it is very easy to manipulate surveys like this; accordingly, it is not a great idea to take them at complete face value until you can audit votes. since we don’t have a foolproof, private system for doing that yet, these caveats are necessary to make any kind of vote involving site policy work.

(we do eventually want to create a foolproof enough private system, but this is way on the backburner and i’m guessing most of you prefer having an imperfect way to chime in on the site’s direction than none at all until this system is created)

  • Auzy@beehaw.org
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    I’ve noticed some of lemmy in general is turning super toxic. At the beginning it was so positive, but it now feels like the wrong people have been attracted in some servers

    Not sure which servers, but the reality is, if something isn’t done, there is no point of me being here (it literally feels like the fatpeoplehate/thedonald crowd has started moving here)

    In fact, the positive environment was one reason I donated to beeshaw originally. We need more places like this. Everyone does

      • alyaza [they/she]@beehaw.orgOPM
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        19
        ·
        1 year ago

        But defederate the main lemmy instance? Self-defeating.

        just to be clear: we don’t think there’s intrinsic value in federating with the largest communities just because they’re large, and we will never federate (or maintain federation) with a community purely on the basis of its size or ostensible contribution to the fediverse’s activity.

          • Seathru@beehaw.org
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            7
            ·
            edit-2
            1 year ago

            Your opinion. But fact is, their choice is why some of us are here. Yes, I would like articles posted to lemmy.world to show up on my all feed here; No, I absolutely would not like to see lemmy.world’s entire userbase here. It would overwhelm the small mod team and likely kill the vibe. The slight inconvenience is worth it.