Was Captain Janeway in the wrong during “The Gift”? - eviltoast

Did Captain Janeway do the morally right or morally wrong thing refusing to let Seven of Nine return to The Collective?

  • hopesdead@startrek.websiteOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    edit-2
    2 months ago

    Set aside the predictability. Would you say the same goes for “Day of Honor” when Seven is willing to give herself up?

    • remotelove@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      2 months ago

      Standby. I remember the episode but not with enough detail to discuss.(I’ll get it rewatched now.)

      (New reply)

    • remotelove@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      2 months ago

      I watched through Day of Honor a couple of times today, but it was kinda choppy for me since I had to work.

      I just want to clarify “give herself up” in that you mean she is willing to become part of the Voyager “collective” and puts aside her need to return to the Borg?

      If my above assumption is correct, then yes. She is growing exponentially personality wise, but there are significant challenges in doing so.

      Personally, I have been around engineers my entire life. Some people I know could rattle on for hours over something like p vs np even if they just learned about it a few hours ago. Put that same person in a complex social environment and they are absolutely clueless. It’s similar to Seven.

      Assuming I didn’t know anything about her timeline after Day of Honor, my guess would have been it would take years for her to learn how to operate in a complex structure like we are accustomed to. Janeway seems bright enough to understand that as well. So yeah, it would be a very long time before she could make the kinds of decisions we take for granted and Janeway would have to do that for her like a parent.

      Fast forward a bit to Picard, you can see how long it took for her character to develop into something that didn’t resemble a robot. (I am willfully excluding some later episodes of Voyager that were kind of odd, btw.)