I have recently got into mapping traffic signs and speed limits where I can, but I realised I don’t know what to do when mapping differing speed limit signs that are offset from each other. It’s a transition from a 50km/h zone to a 60km/h zone but the signs are offset by 65m, making a sort of “no-mans land” in-between. I plan to map it with the in-between zone tagged with separate maxspeed:forward
and maxspeed:backward
tags. I assume it should be done this way because as a driver on the ground I would follow the speed limit signs on my side of the road as I passed them, having no knowledge of the reverse sign.
I guess I’m wondering if this is a logical way to map this?
Couldn’t you just create dedicated tags for the individual directions of the lanes? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:maxspeed mentions this in the Lanes section.
@sven @openstreetmap I think the tagging you’re showing *should* be fine, but as I think the
:forward
andbackward
tags aren’t as widely supported I’d put the lower speed as a genericmaxspeed
for that bit of road as well. That way simple software will default to the lower limit and more sophisticated software will use the correct one.That’s a good point! Keeping compatibility is important.
I plan to map it with the in-between zone tagged with separate maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward tags.
Maybe it would be better to use the lower speed limit in the “no-man’s land”, since it would be unfortunate to be driving too fast while thinking one is folliwing speed limit. I assume it’s kind of ambigous what the allowed speed limit is?
For mapping, I agree with your logic. I just think we should err on the side of causion when things are ambigous.
Interesting. I just found this instruction. I’m guessing you already did too. (Source)
For speed limits depending on the way direction, see maxspeed:forward=*.
So I would say, map that section of road with forward/backward speeds. Also, the signs should be independent nodes.
The position of the actual speed limit signs can be added as nodes beside the road/railway/waterway