Vibram V-Trail vs Xero Mesa Trail - eviltoast

Im looking for a new running shoe and I am choosing between a few different models, but first my preferences:

  1. As much barefoot feel as possible

  2. Can negate sharp rocks

  3. Water resistaint

That said. I can take it, if the sharpest of rocks give me discomfort rather than pain.

I can sacrifice a bit of water resistance if it dries fast and does not smell awful when gotten wet.

Contenders:

Vibram:

  • V-Trek
  • V-Trail 2.0

Xero:

  • Mesa Trail 2
  • Mesa Trail WP
  • Scrambler low