QOTD: If you could add one feature to Godot, what would it be and why? - eviltoast
  • mindbleach@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    A boring alternative interface would be nice. Properly Windows 95 fare: element hierarchy made crystal clear with relief-shaded borders, fat margins on any nested elements, labeled-by-default icons, “multiple document interface” instead of modes or tabs. Look. Blender’s a lost cause. 3D software is universally going to be inscrutable, because you’re decorating a room through the keyhole. But sometimes this software has a learning curve like the white cliffs of Dover, and even after learning the right answer, I cannot imagine why that’s the right answer.

    This is unlikely to happen mostly because the worst decision software can make is two decisions. Established users don’t want to deal with the ambiguity of having two non-overlapping ways to do everything. Developers sure as heck don’t want to do everything twice just to make it-- not even simpler or easier, but more “discoverable.”

    What’s more plausible is recapturing how Flash worked on the web. Some one-line / one-file way to drop in a whole-ass game. Even if that means cramming every asset into the same bulging JS file. One that looks for an appropriate rectangle of Canvas to emit graphics, and if it doesn’t find one, offers to create one anyway.

    I guess the hard part in that case is trying to prevent what Flash on the web did for advertisers. A lot of neat browser features are effectively impossible because of an arms race by greedy idiots.

    • XPost3000@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      1 year ago

      Honestly I’m the opposite, I want godots window manager to be more like blenders

      Blender just does it so flexibly, and the minimum size of the panels isn’t actual continents in size, so I can actually shove stuff out of the way that I don’t need instead of having between 30%-60% of the screen being wasted at all times

      Godot has improved this a bit in 4.1, since now you can pop out the scripting and shading workspace into new windows, but it’s not nearly universally implemented like blender, you can’t pop out the animation editor, the audio buses, the output panel, the debugger, and absolutely worst of all is that you can’t pop out the viewport, even if you press the “distraction free mode” button, the bottom panel still eats like 20%-30% of the screen

      Which means there’s no way to quickly preview what the games gonna look like at corner-to-corner full screen without launching the game and waiting for it to load

      This is even worse if you need to have multiple viewports open, because they all share that same limited space with no option to pop one out to a second monitor

      GD’s window manager is just incomplete compared to Blender, and I far prefer Blender’s way of doing things

      • Rodeo@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 year ago

        Blender’s UI regions are a thing to behold. Never seen any program as flexible and yet easy to customize the UI. It’s a thing of beauty and it’s a damn shame it hasn’t been copied.