The power of context is truly remarkable. Max Fosh convinces coffee nerds that the worst coffee possible, is actually nice.
I am quite annoyed by this, since I know from experience how big the difference is between expensive and cheap coffee.
I’m guessing it was serving it cold that made the trick plausible. Or is it true what normies think of coffee people? That coffee is just coffee, it’s not that deep. I disagree personally.



coffe has more aromatic compounds than wine. Everyone who thinks that coffee is just coffee and specialty coffee nerds are just pretending doesn’t know what they are talking about.
Coffee roasters wouldn’t need to do cuppings and wouldn’t need to bring sample roasters to coffee farms to sample the coffee. They wouldn’t need to travel to different farms that produce different varieties at different elevations with different soil conditions. Farmers wouldn’t need to research and develop different processing methods. Roasters wouldn’t need instruments to measure moisture content in coffee beans and roast level metrics, to create reproducible roast profiles.
All of the above are things the consumer doesn’t see and in most cases doesn’t even know about. So from a business point of view those things would be a huge waste of money if it didn’t impact the flavour.
I think you’re correct.
I met a coffee farmer just last week who was saying that the old way of testing moisture in beans was done was biting softly on them, that it had been done that way for centuries, and that it’s still quite accurate compared to modern machines. Then he bit into a bean right in front of me and said it had 12% humidity before testing it in a machine that confirmed his belief.
Our rightful hatred of capitalism has us (including me) jump to the conclusion that EVERYTHING is marketing bullshit, because it sooooo often is, including with coffee, but there is also a deep expertise underlying it that rich country coffee drinkers never think about because they never see it. They just want their coffee from a trendy coffee shop so they can post it on Instagram, and they assume it’s high quality because they’ve been taught that a brand somehow imparts quality.
When my geography allows it, I get my coffee either directly from farmers, or from very small roasters who literally go pick it up directly from farmers. There is zero exaggeration in the previous sentence. Those who haven’t tasted such quality would easily be fooled by some jackass with gas station coffee.
Last note in this rant, it’s the beans and how they’re grown that matters. It’s the type of processing done to the beans by farmers that matters (washed, honey, natural). The job of the roasters in rich countries is not to fuck up all that meticulous hard work, yet they almost always do. These growers have deep expertise. I’ve seen their processes with my own eyes, although I’m too dumb to understand all the intricacies.
The whole specialty coffee world is such a niche market that it is, at least in my opinion, vastly occupied by enthusiasts that work in this field not because they want to make money but because they are passionate about coffee. They also usually try to use fair(er) supply chains and (try to?!) minimize unequal exchange. Profit margins are much smaller in specialty coffee because of this.
The bigger industrial roasters work by other incentives. I wouldn’t say that they fuck it up because of incompetence though. They usually use lower quality coffee in the first place and then roast them darker because their main goal is consistency rather than exaggeration of origin characteristics. They then use manipulative marketing to hide all the shitty stuff they have to do to get to the cheaper and more consistent end product (essentially pretending they’d do all the stuff the specialty coffee roasters actually do).
But in general i’ll have to admit that coffee drinking the way we in the global north do is very unsustainable. I usually try to buy raw beans directly, roast them myself and drink less but better coffee, rather than a lot. I am very passionate about coffee but i once estimated the amount of coffee plants i would personally need to sustain my own coffee consumption and let’s just say i’d need a pretty big garden …
Whilst I do think conscientious farmers are the best thing, the humidity story could be an easy trick. He could’ve measured before and then ‘tasted it by the chewing method’.
I mean marketing bullshit isn’t only perpetrated by big business only.
I get what you’re saying, but that wasn’t the case here. He walked in late to a presentation and as some beans were being passed around, he randomly grabbed one and told us about the biting method. Also, he wasn’t there to sell anything.
TBF, wine makers have done a LOT of things for centuries that customers didn’t know about and turned out to be useless too.
True but that is true for all sorts of explortations. Sometimes you throw shit at the wall and see what sticks. There are a lot of things in coffee as well that used to be best practices and are now considered useless, outright negative or just not proven to do anything yet. Variable RPM in electric grinders comes to mind. Afaik nobody knows for sure whether that does anything. Especially in espresso making there are a lot of unsubstantiated and sometimes even detrimental takes on how to prepare the puck correctly. This is probably partially due to the fact that those products are so widely available and it is somewhat easy to experiment with them. You cannot expect rigorous scientific explorations from everyone though.
There are, however, also peer reviewed, scientific studies done on both coffee and wine and there is more general knowledge about chemical and biological processes involved in processing and growing coffee and wine that we have a good understanding of. So not everything is pseudo science and smoke and mirrors.