And it seems to me that that is also what the tweet is saying. I don’t see any difference between what the tweeter wants and what my spouse and I have.
Edit to add: You came out swinging stating that this tweet is categorically unhealthy, and then arguing your point by reading “silent” as “bad mood” which is not in any way implied by the tweet. All the tweeter wants is a partner whose response to a change in behavior is curiosity/concern/empathy instead of anger/blame.
My husband and I usually tell one another when we’re in a bad mood and why we’re quiet. We then give each other the space or support that the other needs. That’s healthy communication in my experience.
The tweet is putting the burden on the partner to notice the OP’s moodiness and to ask “why” without any input from OP other than acting different.
I added this as an edit to my previous response, but it does directly address your response so I’ll put it here too:
“You came out swinging stating that this tweet is categorically unhealthy, and then arguing your point by reading “silent” as “bad mood” which is not in any way implied by the tweet. All the tweeter wants is a partner whose response to a change in behavior is curiosity/concern/empathy instead of anger/blame.”
It appears to me that the entire conflict in this thread is due to the interpretation of silent as bad mood and asking why as being the point instead of the reaction being the issue.
Edit: Does that seem like an accurate read to you?
I disagree that your initial response added anything meaningful to the conversation, other than to stoke further discussion, which if that is what you were hoping to accomplish you did so with aplomb. And that’s great, and welcome. My position is that responding to silence (whatever the reason) with violence is abuse. That in no way undermines your point that using silence as a tool for manipulation is also abuse.
The tweet though simply states a desire for a partner who reacts with empathy instead of anger as something to build towards in partnership, and is actually pretty un-vague about it. That feels pretty healthy and uncontroversial to me personally. Perhaps it is merely a difference of interpretation, but the language of the tweet is pretty cut-and-dry in my opinion.
I appreciate the discussion, and agree with your stance about abuse in relationships, I just disagree that the silence in the tweet is the abuse, and not the anger at it.
I was simply pointing out that stonewalling or giving the silent treatment isn’t healthy either
This is the entire issue though, nowhere in the tweet is stonewalling or giving the silent treatment implied. It simply states that they are silent all day, clearly the wanting to be asked “why” implies a desire for empathy and understanding as opposed to being met with anger and frustration at being quiet.
Thanks for editing after I replied.
I wrote and posted the edit before I saw your reply, and then also replied to your reply. So Idk what you’re on about here.
And it seems to me that that is also what the tweet is saying. I don’t see any difference between what the tweeter wants and what my spouse and I have.
Edit to add: You came out swinging stating that this tweet is categorically unhealthy, and then arguing your point by reading “silent” as “bad mood” which is not in any way implied by the tweet. All the tweeter wants is a partner whose response to a change in behavior is curiosity/concern/empathy instead of anger/blame.
My husband and I usually tell one another when we’re in a bad mood and why we’re quiet. We then give each other the space or support that the other needs. That’s healthy communication in my experience.
The tweet is putting the burden on the partner to notice the OP’s moodiness and to ask “why” without any input from OP other than acting different.
That’s a very healthy behavior for sure.
I added this as an edit to my previous response, but it does directly address your response so I’ll put it here too:
“You came out swinging stating that this tweet is categorically unhealthy, and then arguing your point by reading “silent” as “bad mood” which is not in any way implied by the tweet. All the tweeter wants is a partner whose response to a change in behavior is curiosity/concern/empathy instead of anger/blame.”
It appears to me that the entire conflict in this thread is due to the interpretation of silent as bad mood and asking why as being the point instead of the reaction being the issue.
Edit: Does that seem like an accurate read to you?
Do you not understand what the word “either” was doing in my initial statement?
I was adding to the discussion.
Silence ≠ stonewalling
The “either” in your initial response implies that the silence is the problem, not the response to it.
The silent treatment is a known abuse tactic, so yeah it can be a problem.
Both can be problems.
It can be for sure, but that is not what the tweet is about. You are making a false equivalency, tis that simple.
The tweet is vague enough to be open to many different interpretations.
I can just as easily tell you that you’re giving too much grace to OP.
Its meant to spur conversation and that’s been accomplished.
I disagree that your initial response added anything meaningful to the conversation, other than to stoke further discussion, which if that is what you were hoping to accomplish you did so with aplomb. And that’s great, and welcome. My position is that responding to silence (whatever the reason) with violence is abuse. That in no way undermines your point that using silence as a tool for manipulation is also abuse.
The tweet though simply states a desire for a partner who reacts with empathy instead of anger as something to build towards in partnership, and is actually pretty un-vague about it. That feels pretty healthy and uncontroversial to me personally. Perhaps it is merely a difference of interpretation, but the language of the tweet is pretty cut-and-dry in my opinion.
I appreciate the discussion, and agree with your stance about abuse in relationships, I just disagree that the silence in the tweet is the abuse, and not the anger at it.
Thanks for editing after I replied.
I was simply pointing out that stonewalling or giving the silent treatment isn’t healthy either
This is the entire issue though, nowhere in the tweet is stonewalling or giving the silent treatment implied. It simply states that they are silent all day, clearly the wanting to be asked “why” implies a desire for empathy and understanding as opposed to being met with anger and frustration at being quiet.
I wrote and posted the edit before I saw your reply, and then also replied to your reply. So Idk what you’re on about here.