Questions about caddy as an alternative to traefik, with docker, and docker-compose - eviltoast

I currently use docker-compose to manage a number of containers, and I’ve been using traefik as a reverse proxy and to interface with letsencrypt for management of SSH keys.

However, I’ve also been reading a bit about caddy, which seems like an easier alternative to traefik, in the sense of its handling wildcard certificates. All my containers have a public facing url, like this:

blog.mysite.org

mealie.mysite.org

nextcloud.mysite.org

photos.mysite.org

which I would have thought would be tailor-made for caddy. However, in my rough searches I haven’t found out quite how to set up caddy to do this. I’ve also read (can’t remember where) that this use of caddy is ok for homelab, but shouldn’t be used for public facing sites.

So I just need a bit of advice - should I indeed switch to caddy, and if so, how? (All I need is a few pointers to good examples.)

Or should I stay with traefik, in which case, what is the easiest setup?

(I got some help with traefik a few years ago, but I’m having a lot of trouble now extending my current config files to manage a new container.)

I’m also very far from being a sysadmin expert, I usually flail around until something works.

Thanks!!

  • amca01@alien.topOPB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    I have several issues with traefik: first is that I can’t access the dashboard. The second is that as I was given a LOT of help setting it all up (some years ago), I’ve ended up with config files that I don’t fully understand myself. When I tried, for example, to use traefik for certificates to protect my installation of mealie, I simply couldn’t. So my mealie instance is unprotected, running just with http.

    I’m getting to the stage where I’m thinking about paying for some professional sysadmin time … As I said in my OP, I’m nowhere near competent as a sysadmin, especially with networking, and if I can get something to work, I’m thrilled and never want to touch it again, in case I break it.

    • kevdogger@alien.topB
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      Yea I get it…traefik very intimidating at first but I sware if you play around with it for a day or two like a lighbulb will just turn on…it’s super confusing at first. Obtaining certs should be fairly easy and in terms of dashboard…that shouldn’t be that hard to access either