Is M1 MacBook Pro Logic Board Failure Common? - eviltoast

Had a 13 inch MBP M1 that recently turned off and never turned back on, unfortunately no AppleCare for this product but it was babied and really never left its desk for the most part.

I’m seeing this is pretty common with plenty of posts about Logic Board Failure.

Any way to gauge how common it is?

I understand Warranty only covers these things for 1 year but it will always be incredible to me that selling products for thousands that turn out to be bricks quite quickly has no additional consumer protections.

(Already bought a new MacBook to replace and added AppleCare this go around, but still just a bit wild to me that this device is bricked without another $700 into it, and even with that $700, would only then be covered for 90 days)

Thanks for any input!

  • kindaa_sortaa@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Makes sense to be frustrated. I too would be in your shoes.

    Keep in mind Apple sells 25 million Macs per year, so if there’s 75 million Apple Silicon Macs, there’s definitely going to be a few thousand logic board failures out in the wild. That doesn’t mean that even .01% of Apple Silicon Macs get logic board failures—we don’t know.

    So to answer your question: is logic board failures common? That depends on who you ask. A Genius Bar personnel is going to say yes because everyone in their city that gets one will make an appointment at the Genius Bar, so it’s a common issue they see. And if you ask someone with a logic board issue they will say, “yes, its common,” because they found uses in alike situations, and so that bias will carry across as feeling common. But statistically speaking it’s likely extremely rare, at least within the first three years of ownership.

    I understand Warranty only covers these things for 1 year but it will always be incredible to me that selling products for thousands that turn out to be bricks quite quickly has no additional consumer protections.

    If you’re in the U.S., you can thank our government for low consumer protections that favors Fortune 500 over the middle class. I believe you’d be covered in Western Europe for several years past purchase.

  • UnnamedStaplesDrone@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Working at a repair depot, no it’s not common at all unless it has had liquid or food spilled inside of it. They’re pretty reliable for the most part.