Why is apple being held to a higher standard than other tech companies? - eviltoast

so this is something that I find interesting.

every tech company was plagued with issues at one point or another, apple had their fair share and so did any other company. the thing is - when a flaw is found on apple products people blow it to huge dimensions. apple customers (me included) expect perfection, we expect a flawless product right out of the box, but when we don’t get it we judge apple quite harshly.this is some thing iv’e never noticed with any other tech company. why?

I think this comes down to marketing and reputation.

as an example, let’s compare Apples reputation with Google and Samsung - the companies making the leading android flagships in the iPhone pro line price range:

Google is known as software company, people see their pixel line as the only way to get the vanilla android experience without bloatware - as such, they don’t expect the pixel line to be in the forefront of hardware innovation - and indeed their tensor chips are extremely underwhelming. people buy pixel phones for vanilla android and have no other expectations.

Samsung always had a reputation for half-assing new technologies and rushing them in order to be the first with a product utilizing the new technologies in the market. this is evident back in the days of the galaxy s4 which had face unlock years before apple launched Face ID, and in some parts of the world used their own exynos chip which was the first octa core chip utilizing ARM’s big.little in a smartphone - problem was that the face unlock didn’t work more than 50% of the time, and the exynos chip had a design issue that allowed either the 4 performance cores to be active or the 4 efficiency cores, which resulted in the galaxy s4 running slower and hotter than the iPhone 4 with a dual core chip. this tradition continues over the years with the galaxy watch, curved displays, and foldable phones. as a result, while on paper the galaxy phones are technological marvels, this doesn’t translate well to real world use as they are full of gimmicks and bloatware and become sluggish after very little time.

now we get to Apple. apple always had the reputation of a high quality brand. they would be behind the competition in terms of features, then roll out a feature that would not work seamlessly and perfectly for the end user.

but not only that - unlike other tech bands, Apple also brands their products as a fashion statement and a status symbol. comparing an iPhone to to any other flagship phone is like comparing a Swatch to a Rolex, sure, both are watches and both tell the time, but a Rolex is made from premium materials, with utmost precision and regard to little details.

the way Apple markets their own brand causes their customer base to expect perfection from them.

obviously this affects how mistakes made by apple are blown out of proportion and remembered for years at a time while Samsung’s exploding battery fiasco has fizzled out and is largely forgotten by now.

but this also comes into play in what we expect when we buy an apple product:

- when people complain about cosmetic imperfections in their apple products the comments are encouraging them to replace it. since this is unacceptable for an expensive apple device to be imperfect, while for other manufacturers, the comments ae mostly “it’s a tool, use it and stop worrying”

- people are willing ro engage in endless replacement loops hoping to find their perfect unicorn device that has not even the smallest scratch, nick, dent, scuff, display unevenness or any other imperfection.

- even I, when I buy an apple product I inspect it the same way I would an expensive watch or piece of jewelry, and I always find some kind of blemish. I only recently learned to lower my standards as I come to realize that the perfect unicorn device does not exist and trying to endlessly replace devices will only waste my time and not bring me closer to getting said perfect unicorn device.

I think this could be solved in 2 ways:

  1. lowering expectations - change the marketing strategy so that the brand is no longer synonymous with premium quality, and lower prices. but this would of course hurt Apple’s brand image which differentiate them from other tech companies
  2. raise standards - implement stricter QC protocols, send Apple’s own QC engineers to oversee the process in factories, make warranty more flexible, maybe release devices that allow for certain cosmetic issues to be fixed on the spot, similar to how a watchmaker can polish watches. this would obviously cost a lot of money, and i’m not sure it is even possible at the large rates most apple products are manufactured at.

what do you think? is that even a problem? if so, how should it be addressed?

  • Bacon-80@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Tldr; Apple is held to a higher standard because of how their products are marketed. They’re clean & “luxury” - like the OCD version of a company. If they came out with anything less, their customers would be appalled. They set that standard themselves tho.

  • esmori@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Are they? Apple products have several issues that influencers/reviewers don’t mention. They are afraid of being blacklisted to Apple events/review samples.

    • iOS keyboard auto correction
    • Siri
    • notifications
    • JIt restriction
    • App Store monopoly
    • NFC restrictions
    • etc
  • Highlander198116@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Because if I want to repair my 2-4k laptop the Genius bar is just gonna tell me I’m better off buying a new one, when the reality is it could be fixed for far cheaper, but Apple does everything in it’s power to prevent end users from being able to get their apple products repaired at reasonable prices when they are out of warranty.

  • macbrett@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Apple has always been subject to great scrutiny and criticism since before the iPhone even was released. Some of the hate is a reaction to Apple’s inflated marketing “It just works”, “It’s magical.” and touting “new” features that others had already done earlier (at least in some form). Some is backlash to how loyal and effusive its customer base is, and their ability to overlook what are perceived as shortcomings by certain market segments whose desires are not being addressed.

    I think that some criticism still comes from longtime Apple haters who resent the fact that the company didn’t just die in its beleaguered days before Steve Jobs returned to the company.

    As an Apple customer since 1984, I feel that Apple deserves to be criticized for some things like not having user upgradable RAM and mass storage, not supporting third party repair shops with OEM parts to make affordable component level repairs instead of expensive entire subassembly swaps. Overcharging for memory upgrades at time of sale. Trying to milk additional income by providing only minimal default cloud storage. Why is there no option for a cellular modem in the Macbooks? (iPads have it.). I’m sure there is more.

  • Lancaster61@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Apple isn’t the only one. People is like this with Tesla too. As a Tesla owner of 2 of their vehicles, it’s not any worse than any other cars I’ve owned before.

    However Apple and Tesla news generate clicks, so anything outside of absolute perfection generates clicks.

  • 0Sunset@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    If you want to send a message, you go after the one most companies are trying to emulate. There’s more to it like the fact that Apple restricts you on how you use their devices, as they want to be the end all, no alternative services without them profiting. For example, I can use the Aurora store, or f-droid on Android if i don’t want to use Google’s Play store

  • Redhook420@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Probably because Apple markets their products as being perfection and charges a price to match.

  • Rhed0x@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    as an example, let’s compare Apples reputation with Google and Samsung - the companies making the leading android flagships in the iPhone pro line price range:

    The iPhone 15 Pro Max is 300€ more expensive than my Pixel 8 Pro was…

      • Rhed0x@alien.topB
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        Yes but the iPhone 15 Pro is the small model. The small Pixel 8 (the regular one) is even cheaper.

        So if you (like me) want a big high refresh rate screen, the iPhone is way more expensive.

        • Hopeful_Cold3769@alien.topOPB
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          1 year ago

          you’re right,

          the way I saw it the pixel 8 pro was in line with the iPhone 15 pro and the pixel 8 was in line with the regular iPhone 15, because there seemed to be major difference not just in screen size but in camera, specs, screen type and exclusive features.

          but for a lot people the main differentiating factor is indeed the screen size

          • Rhed0x@alien.topB
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            1 year ago

            I literally do not give a fuck about the camera. I hardly ever use it. It’s so frustrating that wanting a large screens with a high refresh rate means I also have to pay for all those stupid camera gimmicks. :(

  • Ghostttpro@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Because more people are buying iPhones. iPhones brand yells perfection. Issue occurs and Apple users. “Majority” unite online and it blows up because so many young people have iPhones and spend alot of time online. It’s honestly a trendy topic.

    Majority doesn’t care about Pixel, Samsung because people expect nothing from them.

    iPhone users are easily connected offline and online therefore have more reach.