EU Article 45 requires that browsers trust certificate authorities appointed by governments - eviltoast

EU Article 45 requires that browsers trust certificate authorities appointed by governments::The EU is poised to pass a sweeping new regulation, eIDAS 2.0. Buried deep in the text is Article 45, which returns us to the dark ages of 2011, when certificate authorities (CAs) could collaborate with governments to spy on encrypted traffic—and get away with it. Article 45 forbids browsers from…

  • pandacoder@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    The problem is that you can issue two certificates for one domain from two different CAs. Which one is valid?

    If you only have one of the certificates, you also can’t know that another exists to warn the user that they might be connecting to a government-operated middleman.

    The problem with a government issued CA being trusted is that the government can now issue whatever certificates they want for any website, and then all they need to do is force your traffic to pass through their servers first.

    And no they don’t even need to make fake website clones, they have you connect to their proxy server which has a valid cert, then they have everything plaintext to save off to look at, and they forward the connection to the original website. Reverse proxy servers to accomplish this take minutes to set up.