well that sucks a lot, a bunch of projects including microG have relied on it.
adjacent discussion on microG’s Github: https://github.com/microg/GmsCore/issues/2237
There’s an interesting comment on this post about Graphene OS’ plans in this area, it’s quite a long comment so I’ll link it. The first para reads:
GrapheneOS Foundation has been planning to host a network location service for GrapheneOS and projects collaborating with us for a while now. We’ve received significant funding we can put to use for this to make a high quality, modern implementation on both the client and server side. A new unified app (cellular, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth beacons) for gathering data to publish as fully open data could also be part of it. We also plan to make a SUPL implementation as part of the same service as an alternative to our Google SUPL proxy to replace it as the default in the long term.
for […] projects collaborating with us
welp, there go my hopes for getting it on CalyxOS.
It’ll probably be open for anyone to use. They’ll just be pissy about it.
Can you explain that? Why wouldn’t Calyx collaborate with Graphene? I don’t use either so I don’t know how or what those projects are doing different.
Perhaps they don’t like each other. I’ve used both and they both are similar projects. Graphene is the more security focused one though.
The former lead dev (who is still part of the team) seems to think many people are out to get him for no good reason. He has claimed repeatedly that Calyx devs have sent harassers to target him for years (from spamming gore or nazi content in the matrix channels, to swatting him and almost getting him killed by the police) and that they constantly speak ill of him, but has never actually shown any proof. Instead, he sources his own past claims about how he has shown proof, in a sort of endless loop.
Also, youtuber Techlore made a 5 second joke about GOS’s extreme approach to security in his mostly positive review of it, which the lead Dev took as a personal attack. After which he started attributing harassment to him too. He made a later video talking about it, and Louis Rossman commented on it expressing concern. After which, the lead Dev accused him to being complicit in the harassment.
Eventually he stepped down as project manager, citing how the harassment and bullying he constantly got was too much. But to my knowledge no one has actually seen it ever.
He has since stepped down and it hasn’t had a noticeable impact on the project. Still seems fine.
It hasn’t had an impact since he is still very active. Also presumably he isn’t the only one with the update keys this time around.
Yea, the whole thing has always given me a lot of pause when I comes to GOS. I’m sure it’s still an awesome solution, but makes me think twice. In the end I have literally zero need or desire for anything Google running on my phone so I’m on calyx.
Interesting, the inaccuracy of the MLS was exactly what attracted me to it. I’m not interested in a location service knowing my exact location at any given time. If I’m somehow too drunk to see and realise where I am, I’ll ask somebody.
sad!
